published today in the Italian Insider:
Scores arrested for absenteeism at Naples hospital
By Florence Brock
NAPLES – As many as 55 employees at Loreto Mare public hospital were placed under house arrest Friday by NAS- the branch of paramilitary Carabinieri police responsible for health protection- in a raid after uncovering acts of fraud committed by state health employees during working hours, authorities reported. Doctors, nurses, technicians and janitors were all taken by surprise in a police raid just after 2 a.m. on Friday morning.
After two years of hidden camera footage and tailing, the NAS stormed into the hospital and placed dozens of hospital employees under arrest for fraud and false declaration against the public administration.
Court orders stemming from the District Attorney’s Office for absenteeism at the Parthenope hospital were served to hospital staff. The copious list included a neurologist, a gynaecologist, nine radiology technicians, 18 nurses, six administration employees and 11 janitors. Some were equally national union members. With other 40 people under investigation, the incursion involved over 90 state employees.
Besides the so-called “multiple badge swipes” by some employees, that made it seem like staff was at work when really members were elsewhere, police cameras also documented the absence of the very employees in charge of supervising and ensuring obedience of employee contract clauses, an inside source reported to Il Fatto Quotidiano.
Absent from the hospital during work shifts, one of these employees would be actually be busy working as a chef in a hotel near Naples. Documented proof also evidenced a doctor leaving the hospital during work hours and going play tennis or taking care of personal business like shopping for jewellery.
Over a period of two years, hours and hours of footage and telephone tapping were gathered in over 500 incidents of observation and tailing, leading to the thousands of episodes involving absenteeism.
Two janitors were equally filmed as they were advised daily by a phone call or via message, according to hospital shifts that needed ‘covering’. Apparently, they would swipe up to 20 badges per day in order to clock in and out for fellow colleagues.
Incredibly, all these acts occurred in a public health structure already known for its constant dearth of personnel.
Loreto Mare is yet another public hospital added to the list of public sanitation facilities being probed for absenteeism. From Hospital Ruggi to Cardarelli Hospital, many have been under scrutiny in Campania for fraud.
President of Regional Audit Office Michael Sciascia had already expressed his alarm at the inauguration of the judicial year weeks ago, announcing his solicitation for countermeasures. With recent events involving dubious management of public health facilities involving patients who received questionable health assistance, “once adopted, rigorously enforced disciplinary measures, that include sacking and suspension, would reduce public administration disorganization.”
His strong words were aimed at medical facilities and hospitals that are called upon to guarantee sanitary services, above all therapies. At any moment, they must be able to guarantee proper assistance to the ill.
In a statement released just hours after the police blitz, Governor of the Campania Region Vincenzo de Luca spoke before members of the press at the annual TAR (Regional Administrative Court) inauguration: “We will be irremovable with those who do not do their duty,” he emphasized regarding the absentees investigation where numerous doctors, nurses and administration personnel are involved. “I have already spoken about this matter to the Director General of the Public Health (ASL),” he added.
“In order to give young people in Campania the opportunity to work, the one thing we cannot allow is frivolous chit chat together with demagogy of those who constantly try to shake responsibility onto others. The time for chit chat has run out. I hope this is clear to everyone,” he concluded.